Skip to main content

Ban Jallikattu or Ban Ban Jallikattu?


Ban Jallikattu or Ban Ban Jallikattu?

Meghna ‘Phoenix’ Ghatak


Jallikattu (image source - https://www.business-standard.com/

The demonstration of domination of a ‘supposedly’ untamed beast to cheering spectators has always boosted the ego of men since the initial establishment of human settlements.  While in ancient India, Harappan seals indicate the presence of a bull taming ritual, American settlements in Arizona has been celebrating ostrich racing festivals since the very start and wild west still celebrates bareback bronc riding. All of these historic events have faced criticism from animal welfare activists internationally as bulls, ostriches and horses are broken by professional/amateur riders, by hanging on to their bodies in a stubborn manner. Participants in these sports have precariously risked serious injury as well as death to emerge victorious over the scared, jittery beasts with rules meant to favor the humans. 
Harappan seal featuring bull fighting

In all of the forms of rodeo sports, the said animal(s) is/are released onto the participants, or an arena with/without a jockey trying to ride the animal(s) long enough to fetch a prize either tied its/their body or later on. The animals that survive the sport fetch a good amount and are used as champion breed for mating or are killed at slaughterhouses.  Interestingly, the animals used in all rodeo sports are specially trained and endorsed by various ranches; they are even given weird names for the media and their biders. They are a source of livelihood for many, in the form of animal handling, husbandry, and hospitality and let’s not forget the artistry that goes into the rustic decorations.  
Bareback Bronc riding

PETA, though criticized frequently for raising its voice against Jallikattu rituals that place in India in Tamil Nadu’s Avaniyapuram, Avaniyapuram and Palamedu in Madurai. According to the news sources, more than 2,000 bulls participate in Jallikattu, which means bull embracing, held from 14th January to 17th January this year, as a part of Pongal celebrations. After investigating the sport rituals for years, PETA threw light on the violence inflicted on the bulls in order to provoke them for a better show which led to a ban in 2014 (which was revoked with certain condition in 2016). Other rodeo sport animals have also reported exhaustion, severe punishment on non cooperation, injuries and death which are a direct violation of India’s Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960.
Coimbatore’s Balakumar Somu advocates on banning every rodeo sport that inflicts pain to the animals or none at all, for a lot of rural communities depend upon these festivals for their livelihood. He said that a winning bull in Jallikattu can fetch a farmer 2 lakhs and above while the event itself can fetch the village 15 lakhs and above, for the festival is a platform for them to find buyers. A farmer buys a calf for ten to twenty thousand rupees, takes the utmost care for 18 months to raise him and when the bull matures enough, he is sold in the competition to rich buyers who employ workers to care for the bull. While the organizers spend a hefty sum to prepare the ground and gifts for the annual festival, it’s a year round affair for the Tamil farmers; hence a cultural heritage for them.
Ostrich racing

Despite replacement by toy rodeos at fairs and amusement parks where competitions challenge the competitive ego, these age old sports still draw major crowds. The ethical question that arises here is the way the animals are pushed into the sports against their basal nature amidst loud noises and manhandling crowds. Will it be so difficult to provide different sources of live hood to the rural communities dependent on the conduction of these ‘cultural’ sports? If conducted, can they be done humanely, without inflicting pain and stress, by providing better care to even the animals who lose? It is never an easy step for the humans to put themselves in the hooves of their own captive bovine to understand the impact of their own actions on the environment. We talk of building a better future for our children and yet we, the most learned generation in the history, ignore the environmental encroachment and depletion issues ever threatening to worsen due to lack of proper action.

Will we ever come to term with the ban? If not, then what?

Comments

  1. Boasting of ego MUST NOT involve the lives of innocent animals.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I am an animal lover and I have tried my very best to help as many animals as I can. I do not and will never approve of such practice.

    I have a blog (still new) and I also write about my pets. I hope you can find some time to head over to my site, too. (strange-and-unusual-pukingking.com)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Flattering Fauna of Banasthali University: A Student's Review

The Flattering Fauna of Banasthali University: 
A Student's Review Meghna 'Phoenix' Ghatak



Banasthali University or Banasthali Vidyapeeth is a women only, deemed university established in 1935 by Rajasthan's first chief minister, Pandit Hiralal Shastri. Lovingly known as Apaji; he,his wife, Ratan and daughter, Shanta dedicated their lives to rural reconstruction in Banasthali, a town in Tonk district, near Niwai approximately 72kms southwest of Jaipur. Here, Apaji and Shantabai handcrafted an educational institute for women, brick by brick initially known as ' Jeevan Kutir' that today provides affordable education to girls from provinces with little or less educational opportunities. Unfortunately, Shantabai passed away at the mere age of 12 but her mission lives on, as myriads of Shantas are trained to pass the legacy to the next Shantas.



Today, one simply has to book a train ticket to Banasthali-Niwai railway station or take a Rajasthan roadways bus from Jaipu…

An Eden Garden for Elephants – Wildlife SOS

An Eden Garden for Elephants – Wildlife SOS Meghna ‘Phoenix’ Ghatak
After watching Netflix’s recent film, Holiday in the Wild featuring Hollywood actors Kristen Davis and Rob Lowe rescuing wild elephants in Zambia, I was left wondering about the state of elephant conservation in India. Elephants have reached an endangered status and an uneven sex ratio due to the killing of the male elephants for their tusks and poaching of matriarchs upon contact with human settlements. Despite being highly protected under the Indian wildlife protection act, 1972, elephants have been commercially traded for their tusks, used as sources of entertainment in circuses or, ridden upon in royal weddings, tourism hot spots and temple gates both in Asia as well as Africa.
We wanted to see if conservation work for elephants was as romantic as they had shown in the movie, so we boarded a train to Mathura and convinced an autorikshaw driver to take us to Wildlife SOS – Elephant Conservation and Care Center. Putti…

Water Birds of Bhopal: Shahpura Diaries

Water Birds of Bhopal: Shahpura DiariesMeghna ‘Phoenix’ Ghatak
Every Bhopal dweller who has to commute between Manisha Market, Chunnabhatti, Kolar Road and MP Pollution Control Board, has to cross this man made water body that sits like a bowl collecting rain and sewage water. Surrounded by ornamental palm trees amidst busy traffic flowing from the B and C sectors of Arera Hills and Shahpura Area, the lake is also used for agriculture and aquaculture purposes post its construction in 1974-75. Morning and evening walks in the parks adjacent to the lake, known as Bhagwan Rhishabhdev Udhyan, brimming with young families and energetic toddlers, pushing plastic balls around, is incomplete without staring at the sky changing colors over the still steely hued water. My personal endeavor had been this past ten years, to buy a packet or two of bread from a neighboring Sanchi Milk Store and to drop the bread in the water granule by granule. Schools of fish clamor to gobble them up and chase at e…